ART AS CULTURE
ART AS CULTURE
1. Functions of Early Art:
As I virtually walked through the Lascaux cave paintings, I wondered what the animals and symbols meant. It seemed like the ancient artists were connected to nature and relied on hunting for food. There were many animal pictures, but few people. I think the paintings were a way for them to tell stories about their environment and how they fit into it. The paintings might also have been used for ceremonies, showing their spiritual world. The many animals shown suggest they respected and relied on nature.
I think that the absence of human figures in the paintings is due to their focus on showcasing their relationship with the natural world, daily challenges and visualizing themselves hunting those animals through sympathetic magic. Mainly because most of the animals painted in the caves were predators, such as cave bears and lions, rather than prey. The ancient practice of sympathetic magic involves causing harm to an image of an animal, believing that the real animal would suffer similar consequences. By drawing these images, they may have sought protection or taken on the ferocity and skill of the animals to increase their hunting success.
The Lascaux Cave paintings provide a glimpse into the spiritual practices of cave dwellers or Paleolithic people, their connection with nature, and their struggles and challenges such as hunting and gathering. The presence of multiple animals in a single painting may indicate that they believed in a spiritual connection between humans and animals. The paintings also tell us about their artistic abilities and capabilities to create instruments like portable lamps and lithic tools used for engraving, which were impressive considering the limited resources available to them.
Also, according to the Archeologie.culture.fr "The dating of the parietal figures in the Chauvet-Pont-d’Arc cave shows that engraving and drawing were perfectly mastered as of 30,000 years BCE."
The Paleolithic people had to overcome problems with darkness, humidity, and rough terrain to create these paintings. They had to represent three-dimensional space with limited colors, using a palette consisting mainly of black, dark brown, red, and yellow. To overcome this difficulty, the artist would leave an uncolored space between two anatomical segments that are normally joined or superimposed and created a slightly lighter border to mark the boundaries of the two surfaces. This suggests that art was not just a form of entertainment but a vital aspect of their daily lives.
Speculating on three possible functions of this art to early humans, I propose:
1. The paintings may have played a crucial role in early religious practices, allowing them to connect with their spiritual world.
2. The art could have served as a means of sharing knowledge and stories about the natural world, passing down important information from generation to generation.
3. The collective effort required to create these paintings may have fostered social bonding among the Paleolithic people.
2. Commonalities in Function:
The commonalities I can observe between early human art and modern art forms are that both forms of art serve as a means of self-expression, communication and storytelling. The cave paintings tell stories about the daily lives and myths of the people who created them. Modern art often employs narrative techniques, such as sequential images, comic strips, or graphic novels. The Lascaux paintings feature three-dimensional renderings of animals, using techniques like layering, shading, and texture to create depth and volume. Similarly, many modern artists use 3D modeling and printing techniques to create complex, multi-dimensional sculptures. Additionally, experimentation with materials and collaboration between artists are essential aspects of both ancient and modern art. They also provide a window into the culture and society of their respective eras. Whether it's the intricate cave paintings or modern photography, both forms have the power to evoke emotions and bring people together.
3. Introduce Us to Your Favorite Art:
My favorite form of art is Photography and I think it has become an important part of modern storytelling and self-expression. From capturing breathtaking landscapes to documenting social justice movements, photography has evolved as a means for sharing experiences and perspectives. For those who practice photography, it serves as a means of expressing themselves and sharing their unique perspective on the world. An example of this is the social justice activist David Bacon, who has spent over three decades capturing the stories of marginalized communities. He uses his camera to bringing attention to issues like labor rights, immigration reform, and environmental degradation. By sharing his work, Bacon aims to inspire change and mobilize action.
The culture surrounding photography is vast and diverse, characterized by:
Style: Photography has a wide range of style and aesthetics for example, fine art, documentary, street, landscape, portrait, still life and abstract photography.
Experimentation: Photographers continuously explore new techniques, technologies, and creative approaches.
Storytelling: Photography is a powerful means of storytelling, allowing photographers to convey complex ideas, emotions, and experiences through a single image or a series of images. This can bring attention to social justice issues and inspire people to take action.
Community: The photography community is vast and global, with numerous online forums, social media groups, and in-person events that connect photographers from diverse backgrounds and skill levels.
Innovation: Photography has driven technological innovation, from the development of film to digital cameras, and from printing techniques to editing software. They may use software to manipulate their images, creating surreal or dreamlike scenarios that blend reality and fantasy.
Photography is a powerful art form that has revolutionized the way we communicate and express ourselves. It helps us preserve memories, allowing us to relive and share them with others. Photography provides a visual record of historical events, cultural practices, and natural phenomena, helping us understand the past and appreciate the present.
However, photography also has its drawbacks. The ease of taking photos has led to an overwhelming amount of digital content, making it challenging to navigate and retain information. The widespread use of cameras raises concerns about privacy and surveillance, particularly in public spaces. Photography can be used to manipulate or exploit individuals or groups for personal gain. By acknowledging both the positive and negative aspects of photography, we can work towards creating a more thoughtful and responsible photographic culture that benefits everyone involved.
I found your summary of how you interrepted the cave paintings similar to what I initially surmized. But, interestingly enough, through further research I discovered that the animals portrayed were not the animals these people usually hunted. Also, that these paintings were possibly more of a calender of some sort, possibly animal migration.
ReplyDeleteI would be intersted in what our instructor thinks of this.
Hello. I found your thoughts on photography to be very interesting. I thought also of how photography and these cave paintings are very similar in some ways. In photography one sees something, and they take a picture of it to save it. In these cave paintings, one sees something, and they have painted it to preserve it. Perhaps that purposes of doing these things is different, but it goes to show that as human beings we value conservation. We all want our stories to be told and we all want to outlive ourselves. Art helps us to do this.
ReplyDeleteSection 1:
ReplyDeleteRe: Message... So let's keep in mind what life was like for this population of early humans. They spent their lives daily battling the elements and threats to their own survival and the survival of their extended family. So anything the do that requires as much output of energy and effort as these images do is going to offer some benefit to counter those costs. Given that, perhaps their message here is less passive and carries a more concrete import. Perhaps we need to figure out *who* was the target of their message? Themselves? Future generations of this population? Other human groups? It is easier to figure out what they are saying when you figure out who they are talking to.
Re: Animals... Do we need to imagine an ephemeral concept such as "magic" to explain these images and the emphasis on animals over people?
Are you familiar with the concept of Occam's Razor? It suggests that if simpler explanations work in understanding the function of a behavior or an event, then there is no need to opt for more complex driving forces. This applies here. Instead of "magic", can we look at this from the perspective of basic survival functions, especially since we don't have actual evidence that "magic" was a part of the equation here.
Applying that to this prompt, the humans are essentially stick figures, where the animals are depicted in detail and color. Could it simply be that they knew what humans looked like already? ;-) It was the animals that they needed to record for future information?
Re: Aspects of culture... "The Lascaux Cave paintings provide a glimpse into the spiritual practices... "
What evidence do we have that these served a "spiritual" function? know that the original researchers claimed a religious function, but later researchers opposed that jump in logic, which said more about the biases of the researchers than the intent of the paintings. Occum's razor applies here as well. They do tell us about hunting techniques, about the animals they interacted, and about their artistic talents. Sometimes (like with the absence of people), what is missing tells us as much as what is actually there. Seems like the information in the paintings is solely about hunting. Considering hunting is traditionally a male practice, with women doing the gathering, does this tell you anything about who was doing these paintings? Would the paintings have been different if women were doing the painting?
Re: Difficulties... "Rough terrain"
That's an understatement! :-) Agree with your points here, but they also had to create the tools and pigments from scratch to create these paintings.
Re: Functions... Story-telling is definitely a good possibility as that is common in human populations (Homer made it famous). I think I need more explanation on "social bonding"? How did it accomplish this? And what benefit does this provide?
Regarding a "religious" function, the issue with Occum's Razor again applies. This doesn't rule out a religious explanation, but recognizes this just raises more questions... such as where is the evidence that it IS religious in nature. We can't just assume that.
Possible functions:
a. Story-telling
b. Teaching young hunters
c. Record-keeping
d. Recording events
Google limited the length of my comment so I will finish it here:
Delete______________________________________________________________
Section 2: While I appreciate your discussion here, I acknowledge that modern art can take on this more ephemeral function, but the cave art is high cost and requires a high benefit to make it worth their effort. Art can communicate information and ideas or record events for future populations. It can generate anger or support or passion. It can inspire others to act or bolster a person's courage. It can teach and inform and make people aware of important issues or concerns. One great example of this is photography, which is used to communicate and inform people of events, positive or negative, and can be used to inspire people to act or warn of impending horrific events. Think a bit more deeply on this. How many of these functions can also be applied to these cave paintings?
Section 3: I love it when students raise the art form of photgraphy as that is one of my favorites.
Image/Video: Wonderful.
Function: Good examples. I would argue that photography has carried a heavy influence on our society since it was created. Think about it... before photography, we relied on paintings and drawings, both of which was subject to the bias of the artist... they controlled what they drew. With photography, it is difficult to create bias. The picture is what it is.
Culture: Good thorough exploration here.
Costs/Benefits: Very good coverage of both benefits and costs.
Hello. I thought your post was structured well and very informative. I al.so found that your interpretation of the cave paintings to be similar to mine. I also think that your perspective about photography is quite interesting and can relate to the cave paintings in many ways. One takes phots to capture a moment, saving it in time, this could have been way the cave dwellers were doing with the paintings. Capturing a moment or providing information about an event to save and share with generations to come.
ReplyDeleteI thought the topic of magic was very interesting though if I were to label it myself I might call it spirituality and maybe not yet a form of magic. I personally believe that the paintings have a much more simple meaning that holds other purposes within them. I think they were simply leaving their mark on the world and showing that they were there at some point. This is simple but it is something that people do all the time and besides that there are other benefits with their paintings. They could double as legends of their surroundings and ways to teach young about the world around them. They may have been just been simple self expression.
ReplyDelete